Name: Pizza Man
Price range: $$

Pizza Man Information

Stepping into Pizza Man on 14375 60th St N in Stillwater feels like walking into a neighborhood spot where everyone knows your name, but with a menu that could easily impress a first-time visitor. The aroma of fresh-baked dough hits you the moment you walk in, setting the tone for a meal that’s all about comfort and flavor. The menu offers a solid mix of classic and inventive pizzas, from the perfectly balanced Margherita with its fresh basil and rich tomato sauce to more adventurous options loaded with toppings that never feel overwhelming. Crust enthusiasts will appreciate the thoughtful attention to texture-crispy edges with a soft, chewy center, striking that ideal pizza Goldilocks zone.

Beyond pizza, the menu extends to hearty subs, crisp salads, and flavorful sides that complement the main attraction without overshadowing it. Many diners rave about the garlic knots, brushed with just the right amount of buttery garlic and sprinkled with parmesan, making them a perfect starter or snack while waiting for your pie. The drinks and dessert offerings round out the experience, with ice-cold sodas and sweet treats that feel like an afterthought done with care.

Service at Pizza Man leans casual but attentive, with staff ready to offer suggestions or accommodate special requests. Whether you're picking up a takeout order or dining in, the pace is comfortable, letting you enjoy your food without feeling rushed. The interior is simple and inviting, with a clean, relaxed vibe that encourages lingering over a slice or two. Local reviews often highlight the friendly, welcoming atmosphere as much as the food itself, noting that the staff’s knowledge of the menu and genuine enthusiasm adds to the overall experience.

Pizza Man also taps into the local community, drawing in families, students, and longtime residents alike, which gives the place a lively yet familiar energy. Portions are generous, and pricing feels fair for the quality and taste delivered. The combination of thoughtful ingredient choices, solid execution, and approachable service makes this Stillwater spot a dependable choice when a craving for pizza hits, offering both consistency and a little local charm with every bite.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

I've been ordering since approximately 1998 and not one time have they ever let me down! Tonight we ordered a 16" house special and LG cheese bread and it was delicious and amazing as always! Thanks Eric! Happy new year to you all...

Pizza Man has the best sausage in Stillwater - keeps us coming back - and the sauce has a nice spicy balance. Although they don’t offer thin crust we always ask for their regular crust to spread out more than usual. Has become something of a weekly thing. Want to have some fun - ask them about cutting the pizzas in square or triangular pieces.

Just relocated to Stillwater and have ordered pizza here two times. Absolutely delicious pizza! Better than any chain pizza. Will be our regular pizza place for sure.

It's a great day when Pizza Man is on the table. There's a lot of great pizzas in Stillwater but Pizza Man is really hard to beat. Crust is second to none, sauce is great and they don't skimp on toppings. No dining room so it's hard to rate atmosphere.

Super good local pizza joint!! Check ‘em out, free delivery too is a great touch.

Not only is Eric, the owner, a really nice person, he makes the BEST pizza I have ever had! When I am out-of-state or out of the country, I crave his pizza even more! No one beats his sausage! And, his cheese is the real deal!

Best pizza in town! Why? Real, melty cheese! Thick, rich red sauce! Thin, firm Crust! Generous toppings! Locally owned and operated! Because of the fresh, high-quality ingredients, this Pizza Man earns a 10/10 - Pizza Dude

So sorry to say but I have to update here. Customer service is Extremely Poor. Impatient and Angry. One night my CC failed and when I offered my backup (there was no issue w/my checking; just a call out from bank which does happen for security purposes from time to time). I offered a new card and was yelled at by the service rep and again by the owner telling me they could not accept my new card. I insisted and of course our order went through. This is NOT the first time we've received such inordinate and frankly "angry" service. My ask would be: if you are THAT angry you are in business then DON't be in business at ALL! I have worked the service industry and well know it is NOT easy. You reflect Quite poorly Pizza Man of Stillwater, MN and now your new SIL subordinate. Wish you the best; but I will NOT be ordering again. EVER.

Pizza Man

Pizza Man Information

Most Popular Dishes

Open Times

Pizza Man Gallery

Business Info

Location & Contact

What People's Say About Place

Places Nearby

Celia’S Kitchen - Mexican Food Truck

Bearno's On Dixie

Taqueria Mi Casita Mexican Food

Boulder Creek Coffee

Taste Of New York Pizza

Logan's Bar & Grill At Grouse Mountain Lodge